Best Cooking Sheets: Finding the Perfect Cooking Sheets for You
Who doesn’t love a good home-cooked meal? Even better is when that meal is cooked on your own trusty cooking sheet and not in a dirty old pan. We all know cheap cookie sheets result in blackened or partially cooked foods. And the last thing you want to do is present two-dozen cookies, buttery croissants, or fragrant roasted veggies with burnt bottoms. Lucky for you, we’ve compiled a list of the best cooking sheets on the market.
In this list of the best cooking sheets, you will find a range of top cooking sheet options. This list will highlight different sizes, thicknesses, and materials so that you can choose the best one for your cooking and baking needs. So grab one or two of these baking sheets and start enjoying all of your tasty creations.
When you finish with this list of the best cooking sheets, visit our list of the best cookie recipes and best dessert recipes. These lists will help you put your new cooking sheets to use right away.
Top 12 Cooking Sheets:
1. Nordic Ware Cooking Sheets
Price: $24.99 (2 Count)
Highlights: Made of 18-gauge commercial-quality material, features generous rimmed edges, and has a nonstick aluminum surface.
About Cooking Sheet: This uncoated aluminum half sheet pan is constructed of 18-gauge commercial-quality material, making it sturdy and durable. It also features generous rimmed edges to keep crumbs and spills contained.
Plus, the natural aluminum surface is nonstick, so you won’t have to worry about food sticking to the pan. Whether baking cookies or roasting vegetables, the Nordic Ware Cooking Sheet is an ideal choice for any kitchen.
2. Farberware Ceramic Cooking Sheet
Price: $12.43
Highlights: Non-stick, oven safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, and available in Aqua Blue or Lavender colors.
About Cooking Sheet: The Farberware Ceramic Cooking Sheet is one of the best cooking sheets on the market. It features a textured design that allows for better airflow and even baking. Also, the ceramic coating is nonstick and easy to clean.
The sheet is also oven safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. Available in Aqua Blue or Lavender, the Farberware Ceramic Cooking Sheet is a great addition to any kitchen.
3. Chicago Metallic Cooking Sheet
Price: $21.73
Highlights: Withstands warping and buckling, features a coated surface, has a fine-grained texture, and cooks faster than traditional baking sheets.
About Cooking Sheet: This top-quality option from Chicago Metallic is designed to withstand warping and buckling and features a coated surface with a fine-grain texture that helps prevent cookies from spreading and flattening. Plus, it browns cookies and veggies faster than traditional baking sheets, so you can get the perfect results every time.
4. Vollrath Cooking Sheet
Price: $84.99 (2 Count)
Highlights: 10-gauge aluminum construction, sturdy one-rim design, and open edges.
About Cooking Sheet: This 10-gauge aluminum cooking sheet is built to last, with a sturdy one-rim design that promotes even airflow and consistent cooking results. Plus, the open edges make it easy to grab and rotate in the oven. Whether you’re a seasoned baker or just getting started, the Vollrath is sure to become your new go-to pan.
5. OXO Cooking Sheet
Price: $25.95
Highlights: Aluminized steel, high sides, dishwasher safe, and golden nonstick ceramic coating.
About Cooking Sheet: This heavy-duty sheet pan is made from aluminized steel and features high sides and a textured surface. It’s also dishwasher-safe, so you can easily clean it after use. Best of all, the OXO Cooking Sheet looks great in any kitchen with its golden, nonstick ceramic coating.
6. USA Pan Cooking Sheet
Price: $19.71
Highlights: Made in the USA, has a BPA-free nonstick coating, and features a unique ridged surface.
About Cooking Sheet: Made in the USA from durable materials, this baking sheet is built to last. It features a BPA-free nonstick coating that ensures easy food release, plus a unique ridged surface that promotes even airflow for perfect results every time. Whether baking cookies or roasting vegetables, this sheet will become your new go-to kitchen essential.
7. Good Cook Cooking Sheet
Price: $27.00 (3 Count)
Highlights: Durable, efficient, made with a heavy-duty nonstick coating, and easy to clean.
About Cooking Sheet: Made with heavy-duty nonstick coating, this cookie sheet is ideal for baking all sorts of goodies like cookies, cakes, and biscuits. And because the coating is nonstick, your treats will slide right off the tray- making cleanup a breeze. Durable and long-lasting, this cooking sheet is a must-have for any baker who values efficiency and quality.
8. AirBake Cooking Sheet
Price: $16.47
Highlights: Made of 100% aluminum, features Micro-dome technology, and improves baking time by up to 15%.
About Cooking Sheet: Made of 100% aluminum, this cooking sheet is designed to provide the best baking results every time. It features Micro-dome technology to decrease bake times by up to 15%, making it a great choice for busy households.
Additionally, the two heavyweight aluminum sheets work together to create an overall enhanced baking performance. So if you’re looking for a top-notch cooking sheet that will make your life easier in the kitchen, choose AirBake.
9. Winware Cooking Sheet
Price: $20.34 (2 Count)
Highlights: Made from 20-gauge aluminum, it is tin-thin and warp-resistant, and has a low price point.
About Cooking Sheet: Made from 20-gauge aluminum, this cooking sheet is tin-thin and warp-resistant, meaning it will withstand high heat without breaking down. The nonstick surface means that your food will come off easily, and the pan will maintain its integrity even after multiple uses.
10. Nutrichef Cooking Sheet
Price: $17.93 (3 Count)
Highlights: Includes three sizes, comes with red silicone handles, is dishwasher safe, and has a carbon steel construction.
About Cooking Sheet: This 3-piece set includes small, medium, and large cookie pans, each with red silicone handles. The carbon steel construction and nonstick coating make these pans durable and easy to use. They’re also dishwasher safe, so cleanup is a breeze. Whether you’re baking, roasting, or toasting, the Nutrichef Cooking Sheets are a great choice for all your cooking needs.
11. Anolon Cooking Sheet
Price: $17.49
Highlights: Heavy gauge steel, oven-safe up to 450 degrees, and a unique silicone handle design.
About Cooking Sheet: This heavy gauge steel baking sheet is durable, warp-resistant, and oven-safe up to 450 degrees – making it perfect for roasting, baking, and more. Plus, it’s dishwasher-safe for easy cleanup.
The unique silicone handle design provides a comfortable grip, making it easy to transfer in and out of the oven. With its superior performance and sleek design, the Anolon Cooking Sheet is a must-have for any kitchen.
12. G & S Cooking Sheet
Price: $8.32
Highlights: Nonstick coating, professional-grade steel construction, and a Teflon Xtra finish.
About Cooking Sheet: This pan is perfect for everything from baking cookies to making sheet pan dinners. The nonstick coating ensures easy food release and effortless cleanup, while the professional-grade steel construction ensures even heating with no hot spots. Plus, the Teflon Xtra finish is designed to withstand everyday use.
Editor’s Pick: Best Cooking Sheet for Consistent Results
Editor’s Pick: Nordic Ware Cooking Sheets – The Best All-Around Baking Sheet for Home Cooks
When it comes to balancing durability, performance, and affordability, the Nordic Ware Cooking Sheets stand out as the top choice. Crafted with 18-gauge commercial-grade aluminum, these sheets deliver even heating and are tough enough to resist warping under high temperatures. The rimmed edges help contain drips, making them perfect for everything from roasting vegetables to baking delicate cookies. Their natural aluminum surface promotes a nonstick effect without chemical coatings. For home cooks who want reliable results every time, Nordic Ware is a proven kitchen essential.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Cooking Sheets
What is the best material for a cooking sheet?
The best cooking sheets are typically made from aluminum or aluminized steel, which promote even heat distribution and help prevent burning. Stainless steel is durable but doesn’t conduct heat as evenly, while nonstick ceramic coatings offer easy cleanup but may wear out over time.
Are all cooking sheets nonstick?
No, not all are nonstick. Many high-quality baking sheets, like Nordic Ware or USA Pan, use natural or BPA-free nonstick coatings. If you prefer longevity over convenience, uncoated aluminum or steel may offer better performance over time with proper greasing or parchment paper.
How do I prevent food from sticking to my baking sheet?
Use parchment paper, a silicone baking mat, or apply a thin layer of oil or nonstick spray. Cooking sheets with textured surfaces or ridges, like those from USA Pan or Chicago Metallic, also help reduce sticking by improving airflow.
Can I put cooking sheets in the dishwasher?
Many nonstick cooking sheets are labeled as dishwasher safe, like those from Nutrichef and OXO, but handwashing is generally recommended to preserve their finish. Prolonged dishwasher exposure can degrade nonstick coatings and warp lower-quality sheets.
What size cooking sheet should I buy?
The standard half-sheet size (18×13 inches) is great for most home ovens. If you’re cooking for one or have a small oven, opt for a quarter-sheet pan. Sets like the Nutrichef Cooking Sheet Set offer multiple sizes for versatile use.
Tips for Choosing the Best Cooking Sheet for Your Kitchen
1. Choose the Right Material for Your Cooking Style
Aluminum sheets offer excellent heat conductivity and are great for even baking. Aluminized steel blends heat retention with durability. For easy cleanup, opt for sheets with ceramic or Teflon coatings, but be prepared for a shorter lifespan with heavy use.
2. Look for Warp Resistance in the Construction
Warping can cause uneven cooking and messy spills. Go for heavier-gauge sheets like the Vollrath Cooking Sheet (10-gauge aluminum) or Good Cook’s heavy-duty pans to ensure long-term durability even at high oven temps.
3. Consider Rimmed vs. Rimless Edges
Rimmed sheets help contain juices and crumbs, ideal for roasting or greasy foods. Rimless sheets, on the other hand, make it easier to slide off cookies or pastries. Choose based on what you bake most often.
4. Don’t Underestimate the Surface Texture
Textured surfaces like those on USA Pan help with air circulation and reduce sticking. If you’re baking often, a ridged or patterned surface can give more consistent results with less turning or rotating.
5. Think About Cleaning and Storage
If ease of cleaning is a priority, look for dishwasher-safe models like Nutrichef or OXO. Also consider stackable designs or nested sets to save space in your kitchen cabinet.
Best Cooking Sheets Conclusion
Whether you’re baking cookies, roasting vegetables, or grilling meats, these cooking sheets will help you cook your favorite meals with ease. With any of these pans, you will say goodbye forever to burnt foods and low-quality cooking sheets that never seem to get clean.
So go ahead, give yourself or your favorite cook one of these tested and true cooking sheets! And for more cooking inspiration, take a look at our list of the best cooking blogs.
And for even more excellent cooking-related lists, visit our list of the best baking pans and best kitchen tools. Both of these lists will provide even more kitchen essentials.
Is there a cooking sheet that you think should be on this list but isn’t? Please feel free to share it below if so.
